# Commission

> A commission is the fee a broker charges to execute a trade. Learn the common commission structures, how to measure commission in R, and why small trades pay the most.

Canonical: https://www.journalx.io/glossary/commission

A **commission** is the fee a broker charges to carry out a trade. It is the most visible trading cost, the one that shows up as its own line on a statement, and for that reason it is the one traders tend to check first and then stop thinking about.

What matters is not the commission rate itself but the commission measured against what the trade risks. A dollar figure that is a rounding error on a swing trade can eat a tenth of 1R on a scalp, and that difference decides whether a tight-stop strategy has an edge after costs.

## How a Commission Works

Brokers price commissions in a few common ways, and the structure decides which trades pay the most.

| Structure        | How it is charged                                                       | Example (as published by the broker)                                                                             |
| ---------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| Per share        | A rate times the number of shares, usually with a minimum and a maximum | Interactive Brokers fixed pricing: $0.005 a share, minimum $1.00, maximum 1% of trade value                      |
| Per contract     | A flat amount per option or futures contract                            | Schwab: $0.65 per options contract. Interactive Brokers: $0.85 per US futures contract at its lowest volume tier |
| Per order        | One flat fee no matter the size                                         | Common for OTC stocks: Schwab charges $6.95 per online OTC trade                                                 |
| Percent of value | A share of the trade's notional value                                   | Crypto exchanges' maker and taker fees                                                                           |
| Zero commission  | No commission on qualifying trades                                      | Schwab: $0 online commissions on listed US stocks and ETFs                                                       |

Sources: [Interactive Brokers stock commissions](https://www.interactivebrokers.com/en/pricing/commissions-stocks.php), [Interactive Brokers futures commissions](https://www.interactivebrokers.com/en/pricing/commissions-futures.php), [Schwab pricing](https://www.schwab.com/pricing). Rates change, so check your own broker's schedule.

Every structure charges on both sides of a trade. Buying 500 shares at $0.005 a share costs $2.50, and selling them costs another $2.50, so the **round-trip commission** is $5.00. A 100-share order at the same rate would be $0.50, but the $1.00 minimum applies, which is why small orders pay a higher rate per share than the schedule suggests.

Commissions are often not the only fee on the ticket. Exchanges, clearing firms and regulators charge their own fees, and brokers may list them separately. Schwab's pricing page, for example, notes that it passes through the SEC's Section 31 fee, which is charged on sales of securities. For a journal, the useful number is the total of all of these per round trip.

## Commission in R: The Number That Matters

To see what a commission does to a trade, divide the round-trip commission by the trade's dollar risk (its [1R](/glossary/r-multiple)). That turns a fee into a share of the trade's risk, which you can compare across instruments, sizes and stop distances.

![Round-trip commission as a share of 1R for four trades at $0.005 a share (minimum $1) and $0.85 a futures contract each side. One ES contract with a 4-point stop pays $1.70 on $200 of risk, 0.85%. 500 shares with a $1.00 stop pay $5.00 on $500, 1%. One MES contract with a 4-point stop pays $1.70 on $20, 8.5%. 2,000 shares with a $0.10 stop pay $20.00 on $200, 10%](https://assets.journalx.io/marketing/glossary/commission/commission-share-of-r.avif)

| Trade                        | Round-trip commission | Risk (1R) | Commission in R |
| ---------------------------- | --------------------- | --------- | --------------- |
| 1 ES contract, 4-point stop  | $1.70                 | $200      | 0.0085R         |
| 500 shares, $1.00 stop       | $5.00                 | $500      | 0.01R           |
| 1 MES contract, 4-point stop | $1.70                 | $20       | 0.085R          |
| 2,000 shares, $0.10 stop     | $20.00                | $200      | 0.10R           |

Two patterns show up:

- **Tight stops pay more.** The 2,000-share trade risks less than the 500-share trade but pays four times the commission. With a stop one tenth as wide, even $200 of risk takes 2,000 shares, and per-share pricing charges for every one of them.
- **Micro contracts pay more in R.** An MES contract is a tenth the size of ES (a $5 point value against $50), but the per-contract commission is the same, so the cost is ten times larger relative to the risk. A trader who drops from ES to MES to reduce risk also multiplies their commission per R by ten.

Percent-of-value fees, the norm on crypto exchanges, behave differently. Because the fee scales with position size, its cost in R depends only on the fee rate and the stop distance as a percentage of price. A 0.05% fee each way is 0.10% round trip, and on a stop 1% away that is 0.1R, however much margin the position uses. Our [crypto trading journal guide](/blog/best-crypto-trading-journal) works through this in more detail.

## How Commissions Change Breakeven

Commissions come straight out of [expectancy](/glossary/expectancy), and they raise the win rate a strategy needs just to stay flat. With costs measured in R, the [breakeven](/glossary/breakeven) win rate is:

**Breakeven win rate = (1 + costs in R) ÷ (1 + reward-to-risk)**

| Target | No costs | 0.01R costs | 0.1R costs |
| ------ | -------- | ----------- | ---------- |
| 1R     | 50.0%    | 50.5%       | 55.0%      |
| 2R     | 33.3%    | 33.7%       | 36.7%      |
| 3R     | 25.0%    | 25.3%       | 27.5%      |

At 0.01R, commissions barely move the bar. At 0.1R, a 1R-target strategy needs to win 55% of its trades instead of 50%, which is exactly where the 2,000-share trade with a $0.10 stop sits. Over a year the gap compounds: 500 trades at 0.1R each is 50R paid in commissions alone. The [breakeven win rate table](/blog/breakeven-win-rate-table) lists the full grid at four cost levels.

"$0.005 a share" tells you nothing on its own. Divide the round trip by your dollar risk. If the answer is above about 0.05R, commissions are a meaningful part of whether the strategy works.

## Commission vs Spread vs Slippage

Commission is one of three trading costs, and it is the only one that appears as a separate line.

| Cost                                       | What it is                                                                | Where you see it        |
| ------------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------- |
| Commission and fees                        | What the broker, exchange and regulators charge per trade                 | A line on the statement |
| [Bid-ask spread](/glossary/bid-ask-spread) | The gap between the best bid and the best ask, paid by every market order | Inside the fill price   |
| [Slippage](/glossary/slippage)             | The difference between the price you expected and the price you got       | Inside the fill price   |

A $0 commission broker removes the first row and leaves the other two. For liquid stocks traded in small size, the spread is often the larger cost anyway.

## Key Takeaways

- A commission is the broker's fee per trade, charged on entry and exit. Always think in round trips.
- Measure it in R: round-trip commission divided by the trade's dollar risk. The rate alone does not tell you the cost.
- Per-share and per-contract pricing hit tight stops and micro contracts hardest, because the fee stays the same while the risk shrinks.
- Commissions raise the breakeven win rate. At 0.1R per trade, a 1R target needs 55% winners instead of 50%.
- Zero commission is not zero cost. The spread, slippage and regulatory fees remain.

## Common Mistakes

**Tracking P\&L before commissions.** A strategy that is profitable before costs and flat after them is a flat strategy. Record [fills](/glossary/fill) and fees together so every result is net.

**Comparing brokers by headline rate.** A lower per-share rate with a higher minimum can cost more on small orders. Run your typical order size and stop distance through each schedule.

**Switching to micros without rechecking costs.** Dropping from ES to MES cuts risk by 90% and leaves the per-contract commission where it was, so commission in R rises tenfold.

**Backtesting without costs.** A backtest that charges no commission on hundreds of short-term trades overstates results, often by more than the edge it reports.

**Counting only one side.** A quoted rate is usually per side. A strategy that holds every trade for minutes pays it twice per trade, many times a day.

## How JournalX Tracks Commissions

JournalX records the commissions and fees on each trade from your broker sync or CSV import, next to the trade's P\&L, and shows results in R after costs. Because each trade carries its planned stop, you can see what commissions cost as a share of risk rather than as a dollar figure, and filter by symbol, instrument or setup to find where they take the biggest bite. It is the same idea behind [what to track in a trading journal](/blog/what-to-track-in-a-trading-journal): log the fees as a field, not an afterthought.
